What is PSA BuyBack?
PSA BuyBack is a direct buyer and seller of PSA graded trading cards. We work directly with collectors — no auction fees, no middlemen, no waiting weeks for a sale.
When you sell to us, you get a fast offer based on real market data, upfront PayPal Goods & Services payment before you ship, and final payment the moment your card arrives and is verified. When you buy from us, every card is PSA graded and ships within 2 business days.
Cards We Buy
We buy all PSA graded cards (grades 1–10) across every major category.
TCG
Sports
How Selling Works
Enter your PSA cert number on the homepage. Our system pulls your card details from the PSA database instantly.
Receive an instant offer based on current market value. Most cards get an instant offer. Cards with unusual price patterns are routed to manual review and you’ll receive your personalized offer within 24 hours.
Accept your offer and upload front and back photos of your slab with our requested handwritten phrase. This verifies you own the card and matches it to the PSA cert.
Photos are reviewed automatically. If anything needs a closer look, we’ll review manually within 24 hours. You’ll get an email when verification is complete.
Receive your upfront PayPal Goods & Services payment.
Ship your card to us via USPS. We recommend tracking and insurance for cards over $100.
Upload your tracking number on your shipment page. Your final payment is sent shortly after.
We confirm receipt of your card on arrival.
How Buying Works
Browse our current inventory at psabuyback.com/for-sale. Every listing shows the PSA grade, cert number, and asking price.
Click any card to see full details including grade, description, and high-res photos.
Buy instantly via Stripe secure checkout, or use the Make an Offer form to negotiate directly with us.
We ship via USPS with tracking and insurance within 2 business days of payment confirmation.
Payment Details
Selling: All seller payments are made via PayPal Goods & Services only. This protects both parties and ensures dispute resolution is available if needed.
Payment Split
Offers under $100: 50% upfront before shipping, 50% on receipt
Offers $100 and over: 25% upfront before shipping, 75% on receipt
Buying: All purchases through our store are processed via Stripe, accepting all major credit and debit cards.
Shipping
Selling to us: You cover the cost of shipping your card to us. We strongly recommend USPS with tracking. For cards valued over $100, we recommend adding shipping insurance.
Buying from us: We ship all orders via USPS with tracking and insurance included. Orders ship within 2 business days of payment confirmation.
FAQ
What PSA grades do you buy?
All grades — PSA 1 through PSA 10. Offer amounts vary based on grade, card, and current market conditions.
How long does it take to get an offer?
Most offers are instant. Some cards require manual review, which typically takes up to 24 hours. You'll receive an email either way.
Is payment secure?
Yes. All seller payments are sent via PayPal Goods & Services, which includes full buyer and seller protection. We never ask for PayPal Friends & Family.
What happens if photo verification fails?
You'll be notified by email with the specific reasons. You can resubmit corrected photos. If the card genuinely doesn't match the cert, the offer will be cancelled.
Can I sell multiple cards?
Yes. Submit one PSA cert number at a time through the homepage. Each card gets its own offer and goes through its own verification and payment process.